top of page

Should I Sell My Home With Renters Still Living In It?

The decision to sell your home is a significant one, filled with both excitement and challenges. If you find yourself in the unique situation of having a renter in your home, the decision becomes even more complex. Selling a property with a tenant in place can be a delicate process that requires careful consideration of both legal and ethical aspects.

You should always check directly with your state's landlord/tenant laws, and with the lease agreement itself, to confirm whether you can legally sell your particular property with your tenant still living in it. While most lease agreements and states will allow you to sell your home with an active lease agreement in place, here are some of the factors to consider when contemplating whether to sell your home with your renter still living in it.

First we'll discuss why it might not be the best idea to sell a home with your renter living there, and then we'll provide some tips on what to do if you move forward with listing your home for sale with the tenant in place.

Requirement To Honor The Lease Agreement

It's important to note that, in many states, existing tenant leases are typically legally binding, and you and the new homeowner may be required to honor the continuation of that agreement. This introduces a layer of complexity to the home selling process, as potential buyers may find themselves inheriting a landlord role they hadn't anticipated. Being a landlord comes with responsibilities a home buyer may not be willing to take on.

Additionally, the attractiveness of a property to potential buyers, especially investors, can be significantly impacted if the current rent is below the market rate. If you've been providing your tenant with a discounted rate, or if rental rates have increased significantly in your area since the lease was signed, the new owner may be hesitant to buy a home with less profitable lease terms. The prospect of not being able to adjust rent to align with current market rates can deter potential buyers.

Also, many home buyers are typically purchasing a home for themselves to move into. If the lease is set to end too far in the future, they may not consider your home a viable option for them given their personal timeline. All of these factors can ultimately lead to lower offers as buyers have to consider the downsides of inheriting a tenant and a lease agreement when buying a home.

Tenant Impact On Condition & Showings

Selling a home with tenants in residence can present challenges, particularly when it comes to preparing the property for sale. Tenants may be less inclined to accommodate home showings, making it difficult to showcase the property to potential buyers. Additionally, the process of properly preparing the home for sale (including tidying up for professional photos) and keeping it consistently well-maintained becomes more complex when tenants are involved.

Their priorities may not align with the goal of presenting the property in its best light for potential buyers. This reluctance to cooperate can ultimately impact the marketability of the home and potentially result in a lower sale price. To maximize the selling potential and secure the highest possible return on investment, navigating the dynamics of tenant cooperation and maintaining the home's appeal throughout the selling process becomes crucial.

A Tenant's Bad Attitude

Even if tenants are set to vacate before the closing day, the situation can still pose potential risks for sellers. In some cases, tenants who are displeased with the sale may engage in disruptive or damaging behavior, potentially causing harm to the property before the closing date. Such actions can create a challenging scenario where the seller is obligated to rectify any damages and ensure the property is in the agreed-upon condition before the new buyer finalizes the purchase. This adds an additional layer of complexity to the selling process, underscoring the importance of maintaining open communication with tenants and taking proactive measures to mitigate any potential issues that may arise during the transition period.

How To Sell Your Home With A Tenant Living In It

If your personal or financial situation requires that you move ahead with the process of selling your home while the renter is still living in the home, there are best practice steps you should take to make sure everything goes as smoothly as possible for all involved.

  • Communication is Key: It's crucial to establish open communication with your tenant as transparency is key to maintaining a positive relationship. Inform your tenant about your intentions to sell the property and discuss the potential impact on their living situation. Be prepared to answer any questions they may have and address concerns upfront.

  • Offering Incentives: To make the process smoother for both parties, consider offering incentives to your tenant. This could include a rent reduction for the inconvenience caused by showings or flexibility in the moving-out timeline. You could also offer them money to vacate the property earlier than the lease if you decide selling without them in the home is the best course of action. Incentives demonstrate your commitment to a fair and amicable resolution, fostering a positive relationship with your tenant during the selling process.

  • Timing and Market Conditions: If you have decided to sell your home with your tenant still living in it, the next step is to decide when would make the most sense to put it on the market. The real estate market is dynamic, and timing plays a crucial role in selling a property. Assess the current market conditions and evaluate whether it's an opportune time to sell. If the market is favorable, you may be more inclined to proceed with the sale. You may also want to schedule your first week on market for a time that your tenant plans to be out of the house, for example, while on vacation. Or you could decide to list your home for sale between 60 to 90 days prior to the end of their lease, which could allow them to vacate the property before closing.


The decision to sell your home with a renter still living in it is a nuanced one, requiring careful consideration of legal, ethical, and practical factors. Open communication, understanding lease agreements, and offering incentives can help make the process smoother for both parties. Ultimately, striking a balance between your goals as a homeowner and your responsibilities as a landlord is key to a successful sale while maintaining a positive relationship with your tenant.

If you'd like personalized advice on selling a home in Florida with a tenant in it or selling a home in Virginia with a renter living in it, please reach out to me directly as I'd be happy to discuss your specific situation and offer professional, customized advice.

bottom of page