top of page

Deciding Between Renting and Selling an Inherited Home: A Comprehensive Guide

Inheriting a home often presents a significant decision: should you rent or sell the property? This decision is influenced by various factors, including financial considerations, personal circumstances, and long-term goals. In this blog post, we'll explore the key considerations to help you make an informed choice between renting and selling an inherited home.


1. Evaluate Your Financial Situation: Before deciding whether to rent or sell, assess your current financial position. Consider factors such as outstanding debts, mortgage obligations, and ongoing maintenance costs associated with the inherited property.


2. Market Conditions: Examine the current real estate market conditions in the area where the inherited home is located. Understanding the demand for rental properties and the potential resale value of the house can impact your decision. If the sales market is hot, it may be the best time for you to take advantage of that and sell your inherited home. But if the real estate market is stagnant, holding onto the property in the short-term may prove more lucrative in the long-run.


3. Long-Term Goals: Clarify your long-term goals for the inherited property. If you envision holding onto the property as a source of passive income, renting might be a suitable option. Alternatively, if you need immediate funds or prefer a one-time financial gain, selling could be more beneficial. If you plan on holding onto the home for occasional personal use, reviewing your short-term rental options will be important as well. Some properties are not allowed to be rented short-term, so confirming your plans are feasible is important as well.


4. Maintenance and Upkeep: Consider the condition of the inherited home and the level of maintenance it requires. Renting out a property entails ongoing responsibilities for repairs and maintenance, while selling allows you to pass on these responsibilities to the new owner.


5. Rental Income vs. Lump Sum Sale: Compare the potential rental income with the lump sum you could receive from selling the property. Assess your financial needs and preferences to determine which option aligns better with your overall objectives. Lump sum income might be able to be invested and return more monthly than a rental could. Or owning a rental property could prove much more profitable than investing in other ways.


6. Tax Implications: Consult with a tax professional to understand the tax implications of both renting and selling. Certain tax benefits may be associated with rental income, while selling might have capital gains tax considerations. But rental income may also be taxable, so speaking with an appropriate professional about your specific circumstances is important.


7. Local Rental Market: Research the local rental market to gauge the demand for properties similar to the inherited home. Understanding rental trends and tenant preferences can help you make an informed decision. If you need a property manager to handle renting your inherited home, interview them to find out what they provide and how much they charge.


8. Consider Family Dynamics: If the inherited property is co-owned with family members, open communication is essential. Discussing the pros and cons of renting versus selling can help reach a consensus and avoid potential conflicts.


9. Potential for Appreciation: Evaluate the potential for property appreciation in the area over time. If the market is expected to grow, holding onto the property may lead to increased value in the future. But reviewing the costs to rent and the continued costs of owning a home while you're renting it out is important as those costs may offset potential gains.


10. Personal Involvement: Assess your willingness and ability to be involved in managing a rental property. If you prefer a hands-off approach, selling might be the more convenient option. Even with a property manager, you'll be responsible for handling certain things and making decisions regarding the property.


Conclusion:

In the end, the decision to rent or sell an inherited home is deeply personal and depends on various factors. Careful consideration of your financial situation, long-term goals, and the local real estate market will guide you toward the option that aligns best with your needs. Whether you choose to generate rental income or secure a lump sum through a sale, making an informed decision ensures a positive outcome for both your immediate and future financial well-being.


Disclaimer: I am not an attorney, financial advisor, or licensed tax professional and the content of this blog post should not be construed as legal or financial advice. It is provided for informational purposes only. For specific legal guidance related to selling inherited property or any other legal or financial matters, it is strongly recommended to consult with a qualified professional. Your individual circumstances may vary, and obtaining appropriate counsel is essential to address your specific situation.


bottom of page